📚 node [[canceling contrapoints]]
Cancelling by [[Contrapoints]] YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjMPJVmXxV8 Transcript: https://www.contrapoints.com/transcripts/canceling
-
Cancel Culture Tropes
-
Presumption of Guilt
- “accusation is proof enough”
- “believe victims"
-
Abstraction
-
Replaces the specific, concrete details of a claim with a vague abstraction
-
“Tati accuses James of trying to trick straight men into thinking they’re gay” becomes “James is toxic and manipulative"
- The main call-out was actually that James endorsed a competing hair vitamin product
- Accusation becomes fact. Specific action replaced with vague idea. Actions becomes being (tried to becomes “is”).
- Vague idea possibly has very different connotations. “Sexual preditor” calls to mind very different actions than “tried to trick gay men into thinking they’re gay"
-
“Tati accuses James of trying to trick straight men into thinking they’re gay” becomes “James is toxic and manipulative"
-
Replaces the specific, concrete details of a claim with a vague abstraction
-
Essentialism
- Move from criticising actions to criticising the person themselves.
-
Psudo-moralism or Pseudo-intellectualism
- People are really interested in the drama and schaudenfreud, not their commitment to moral or intellectual standards.
- No Forgiveness
- The Transitive Property of Cancellation
- Dualism
-
Presumption of Guilt
📖 stoas
- public document at doc.anagora.org/canceling-contrapoints
- video call at meet.jit.si/canceling-contrapoints
🔎 full text search for 'canceling contrapoints'